A line from The National's contribution to Dark Was the Night, "So Far Around the Bend" includes the words "praying for Pavement to get back together," which is pretty awesome in and of itself, and got me thinking about my recent list of all-time favorite bands on which Pavement ranked #2. The band hasn't recorded a new album in almost a decade now and even if they got back together, any new music they'd put together would pale in comparison to the trio of classics that kicked off their career, Slanted & Enchanted, Crooked Rain, Crooked Rain, and Wowee Zowee. And not just because Stephen Malkmus' latest album was such a disappointment. All bands have a peak, and almost all bands peak early in their careers, with their sounds and vibrancy changing along with their age. Even the great bands have distinct ups and downs in their discography and almost all later albums, especially after a switch to a major label, are weaker facsimiles of the sound that made them great in the first place. It's no coincidence that the two "older" bands that ranked at the top of my all-time artist list -- The Smiths and Pavement -- both ended their runs "prematurely", after less than a decade, and each after a single final album signaled their first decline in musical quality in
their careers. The rest of my once favorite bands, from U2 to R.E.M. to New Order to The Cure, have either muddled on through in increasing irrelevancy (The Cure), disappeared and come back to middling results (New Order) or have ascended to superstardom with a stale mixture of music that cannot come close to match their 1980s brilliance (U2, R.E.M.). And so those bands did not rank in my top 10 -- or anywhere near it. New Order would probably squeak into the top 20 on my list today, while the others wouldn't crack the Top 50. I watched U2's performance on Letterman on the night Artie Lange was a guess and I made it through maybe half of the song they played before turning it off. There were shades of old-school U2, but it just didn't do anything for me, and I'm pretty sure that was one of the better songs on the new album. You just can't go home again, not in music, not for me. The bands that dropped out at their peak -- without the decline phase of their careers to bring their overall average down -- end up looking greatest in my eyes, and maybe that's not fair, but that's my experience. I guess what I'm trying to say is that I'd love to see Pavement in concert again and I'd love to see them get back together, but if it means they'll be releasing a new album that doesn't come close to the quality they're known for, then maybe I don't. Maybe it's best just to be done when you're done. Yeah, you probably lose out on a lot of cash as a result, but maybe the legacy ends up stronger.
I'll run through a thousand parties
I'll run through a million bars
Nobody knows where you are living
Nobody knows where you are
You've been humming and I think it's forever
Praying for Pavement to get back together
Nobody knows where you are living
Nobody knows where you are
You're so far around the bend