It's been horrible for years, it seems like it's getting worse, but this postseason has been monumentally egregrious. First there was the mug-fest in the Big East championship where Louisville came from way behind by putting on a press that involved full-out tackling of Syracuse players in the backcourt without a call, allowing the Cardinals to get a bunch of easy buckets in a row and all kinds of momentum while the game spiralled out of officials' control until they called a phantom foul on Syracuse (!) on a 3-point shot, then followed it up with a technical on Syracuse (!) after Michael Carter-Williams swatted away a Louisville defender after 2 minutes of nonstop mugging without a call. Anyway, yes I'm still pissed about that game even though Syracuse made the Final Four. Then we all watched Wichita State get robbed by a call that directly led to Louisville's win and in the nightcap, the officials decided to decide the game yet again, yet again going against Syracuse. After playing miserably all night, Syracuse came back due to Michigan's poor free throwing shooting and struggles against our pressure, and we had the ball, down 2 with 20 seconds to play. Brandon Triche made the unwise move of driving from the free throw line to try to score, got called with a charge on a controversial call, fouled out, and after Michigan missed a free throw, little played backup shooting guard Trevor Cooney turned the ball over and the game was over, and Michigan would lose to Louisville in the title game... the two teams that the referees helped most to beat Syracuse this season. Cooney was handling the ball because Syracuse's two starting guards (Triche and MCW) had fouled out. MCW's last 2 foul calls were extremely questionable, and obviously this was the first time all season both of our starting guards fouled out of a game, as Boeheim had only one other scholarship guard on the roster (Cooney) and he rarely played. Long story short, despite how poorly we played and honestly did not deserve to win, the charge call on Triche cost us any chance to tie the game. So what about that call...
Point blank. Period. The NCAA Men’s Basketball Rules Committee issued new guidelines last June for the officiating of blocks and charges:
“Before the offensive player (with the ball) becomes airborne, the defender must have two feet on the floor, be facing the opponent and be stationary to draw a charge. Otherwise, it should be a blocking foul.”
Morgan’s feet were not set and he was not stationary when Triche went airborne. Now, I’m not going to say this alone cost Syracuse the game; they had plenty of chances to win and maybe Brandon should have pulled up, as he said. But, by the letter of the law, it was clearly a bad call. Personally, I can’t stand how the charge has gone from a way to keep an offensive player from simply bulling his way through a well-positioned defender to a way to draw a cheap foul by barely getting set outside the circle as an opponent is making a move to the basket. Officiating in this manner punishes offensive players for taking it strong to the hoop, even when they aren’t necessarily out of control, and Brandon was not out of control as you can see below. (you might need to click on the picture to see the GIF move)
link to full article here
